• Home
  • Staff
  • Privacy Policy
  • News Tips/Press Releases
  • Advertising
Tuesday, March 2, 2021
No Result
View All Result
The Times-Delphic
  • News
    • All
    • Administrative News
    • Campus Events
    • Campus Health
    • Caucus Roundup
    • In Des Moines
    • Politics
    • Student Politics
    • Student Senate
    February brings severe weather, negative temperatures

    February brings severe weather, negative temperatures

    Drake announces room and board fee increase for 2021-2022

    Drake announces room and board fee increase for 2021-2022

    Public Safety investigates stolen catalytic converters

    Public Safety investigates stolen catalytic converters

    Racial Epithets vs Political Disagreement

    Racial Epithets vs Political Disagreement

    Drake Theatre Department Presents Online Musical

    Drake Theatre Department Presents Online Musical

    • Administrative News
    • Campus Events
    • Campus Health
    • Caucus Roundup
    • In Des Moines
    • Politics
    • Student Politics
    • Student Senate
    • Senate Elections
  • Sports
    • All
    • Baseball
    • Basketball
    • Column
    • Cross-Country
    • E-Sports
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Rowing
    • Soccer
    • Softball
    • Tennis
    • Track and Field
    • Volleyball
    Women’s Tennis Begins New Season

    Women’s Tennis Begins New Season

    Buying Tickets for a Chance to Catch a Game

    Buying Tickets for a Chance to Catch a Game

    Women’s Tennis Faces off Against Colorado State University

    Women’s Tennis Faces off Against Colorado State University

    Annual Pink Out game adapts to COVID precautions

    Annual Pink Out game adapts to COVID precautions

    Valparaiso hands Drake Men’s Basketball first loss of the season

    Valparaiso hands Drake Men’s Basketball first loss of the season

    • Basketball
    • Column
    • Cross-Country
    • E-Sports
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Rowing
    • Soccer
    • Softball
  • Commentary
    • All
    • Horoscope
    • Letter from the Editor
    • Letter to the Editor
    Welcome to Class: Savings 101

    Welcome to Class: Savings 101

    Car Accident Sends One Writer on Ride of Shame

    Car Accident Sends One Writer on Ride of Shame

    To all The Boys: Always and Forever: Movie Brings Jams, Tears and Existential Dread

    To all The Boys: Always and Forever: Movie Brings Jams, Tears and Existential Dread

    Big Time Ranked: The Top Ten Big Time Rush Songs

    Big Time Ranked: The Top Ten Big Time Rush Songs

    Hockey Fights Cancer

    Making the Best of 2021

    • Horoscope
    • Letter from the Editor
  • Features
    • All
    • Greek Life
    Drake alum shares career, life after graduation

    Drake alum shares career, life after graduation

    Annual Pink Out game adapts to COVID precautions

    Annual Pink Out game adapts to COVID precautions

    A Conversation with Indira Sheumaker

    A Conversation with Indira Sheumaker

    Indira Sheumaker announces her run for city council

    Indira Sheumaker announces her run for city council

    “Be Unstoppable” Career Fair Offers Networking for Students

    “Be Unstoppable” Career Fair Offers Networking for Students

    • Greek Life
  • Podcasts
    Drake Weekly Sports Podcast | December 3

    Drake Weekly Sports Podcast | December 3

    Drake Public Safety and the student body

    Drake Public Safety and the student body

    Humans of Drake Podcast

    Bulldog Blitz 1: December 7, 2010

    The Sports Report 2010 7: 11/09/2010

  • Relays Edition
    Rainbow Union Empowers the LGBTQ+ Community at Drake

    Rainbow Union Empowers the LGBTQ+ Community at Drake

    Avengers: Endgame Predictions

    Avengers: Endgame Predictions

    Drake professors define their teaching experiences

    Evening at the observatory: Is There an Anti-Me?

    Evening at the observatory: Is There an Anti-Me?

    Bulldogs football completes 9th winning season in 10 years

    You can be the force to finally change Drake’s culture

    Student press is essential for letting students’ voices be heard

    Rolle breaks Drake triple jump record

    Rolle breaks Drake triple jump record

    First-year uses photo talent to market Drake’s campus

    Spanish class spotlights important Latinas

    Blitz Day festivities include revealing Relays concert, theme

    Blitz Day festivities include revealing Relays concert, theme

    • Commentary
    • Coronavirus
    • Elections
    • Features
    • In Des Moines
    • News
    • This week in photos
    • Top News
    • Top Stories
    • Uncategorized
    • Video
    • Sports
    • Security Reports
    • Relays Edition
    • Poll
    • Podcasts
    • Online Exclusives
    • Opinion
  • News
    • All
    • Administrative News
    • Campus Events
    • Campus Health
    • Caucus Roundup
    • In Des Moines
    • Politics
    • Student Politics
    • Student Senate
    February brings severe weather, negative temperatures

    February brings severe weather, negative temperatures

    Drake announces room and board fee increase for 2021-2022

    Drake announces room and board fee increase for 2021-2022

    Public Safety investigates stolen catalytic converters

    Public Safety investigates stolen catalytic converters

    Racial Epithets vs Political Disagreement

    Racial Epithets vs Political Disagreement

    Drake Theatre Department Presents Online Musical

    Drake Theatre Department Presents Online Musical

    • Administrative News
    • Campus Events
    • Campus Health
    • Caucus Roundup
    • In Des Moines
    • Politics
    • Student Politics
    • Student Senate
    • Senate Elections
  • Sports
    • All
    • Baseball
    • Basketball
    • Column
    • Cross-Country
    • E-Sports
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Rowing
    • Soccer
    • Softball
    • Tennis
    • Track and Field
    • Volleyball
    Women’s Tennis Begins New Season

    Women’s Tennis Begins New Season

    Buying Tickets for a Chance to Catch a Game

    Buying Tickets for a Chance to Catch a Game

    Women’s Tennis Faces off Against Colorado State University

    Women’s Tennis Faces off Against Colorado State University

    Annual Pink Out game adapts to COVID precautions

    Annual Pink Out game adapts to COVID precautions

    Valparaiso hands Drake Men’s Basketball first loss of the season

    Valparaiso hands Drake Men’s Basketball first loss of the season

    • Basketball
    • Column
    • Cross-Country
    • E-Sports
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Rowing
    • Soccer
    • Softball
  • Commentary
    • All
    • Horoscope
    • Letter from the Editor
    • Letter to the Editor
    Welcome to Class: Savings 101

    Welcome to Class: Savings 101

    Car Accident Sends One Writer on Ride of Shame

    Car Accident Sends One Writer on Ride of Shame

    To all The Boys: Always and Forever: Movie Brings Jams, Tears and Existential Dread

    To all The Boys: Always and Forever: Movie Brings Jams, Tears and Existential Dread

    Big Time Ranked: The Top Ten Big Time Rush Songs

    Big Time Ranked: The Top Ten Big Time Rush Songs

    Hockey Fights Cancer

    Making the Best of 2021

    • Horoscope
    • Letter from the Editor
  • Features
    • All
    • Greek Life
    Drake alum shares career, life after graduation

    Drake alum shares career, life after graduation

    Annual Pink Out game adapts to COVID precautions

    Annual Pink Out game adapts to COVID precautions

    A Conversation with Indira Sheumaker

    A Conversation with Indira Sheumaker

    Indira Sheumaker announces her run for city council

    Indira Sheumaker announces her run for city council

    “Be Unstoppable” Career Fair Offers Networking for Students

    “Be Unstoppable” Career Fair Offers Networking for Students

    • Greek Life
  • Podcasts
    Drake Weekly Sports Podcast | December 3

    Drake Weekly Sports Podcast | December 3

    Drake Public Safety and the student body

    Drake Public Safety and the student body

    Humans of Drake Podcast

    Bulldog Blitz 1: December 7, 2010

    The Sports Report 2010 7: 11/09/2010

  • Relays Edition
    Rainbow Union Empowers the LGBTQ+ Community at Drake

    Rainbow Union Empowers the LGBTQ+ Community at Drake

    Avengers: Endgame Predictions

    Avengers: Endgame Predictions

    Drake professors define their teaching experiences

    Evening at the observatory: Is There an Anti-Me?

    Evening at the observatory: Is There an Anti-Me?

    Bulldogs football completes 9th winning season in 10 years

    You can be the force to finally change Drake’s culture

    Student press is essential for letting students’ voices be heard

    Rolle breaks Drake triple jump record

    Rolle breaks Drake triple jump record

    First-year uses photo talent to market Drake’s campus

    Spanish class spotlights important Latinas

    Blitz Day festivities include revealing Relays concert, theme

    Blitz Day festivities include revealing Relays concert, theme

    • Commentary
    • Coronavirus
    • Elections
    • Features
    • In Des Moines
    • News
    • This week in photos
    • Top News
    • Top Stories
    • Uncategorized
    • Video
    • Sports
    • Security Reports
    • Relays Edition
    • Poll
    • Podcasts
    • Online Exclusives
    • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
The Times-Delphic
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

Going nuclear

byMATT NELSON
March 23, 2011
in Opinion
0 0
1

Nelson is a junior secondary education major, physics minor and can be contacted at men006@drake.edu

Imagine a pot of spaghetti on the stove with the lid on it. The stove heats up. The water starts to boil. If you don’t turn down the heat or take off the lid, it boils over.

Every first-year student and Sodexo worker inevitably faces this situation. Last week, the technicians at the Fukushima nuclear reactor did as well. The only difference between their predicaments was when the student’s pot boiled over, the mainstream media didn’t immediately assume a radioactive apocalypse was underway.

As an aspiring science writer, I was disgusted by the way the mainstream media treated the recent nuclear crisis. I watched reporter after reporter using volatile language, describing increasing radiation levels and explosions without describing their consequences. This led audiences to assume the worst, when in fact the danger at all times was, believe it or not, fairly minimal.

Here are the five biggest myths I’ve seen perpetuated by the media:

1. The amount of radiation released is somehow lethal.

Many outlets reported that radiation levels had increased by “10 or 100 times” above normal. That’s true, but what most reports failed to mention was that these levels still aren’t dangerous. According to the Nuclear and Industrial Safety Agency, one micro sievert of radiation was released per hour between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. on March 15.

That amount is not hazardous to your health. In fact, if you were continuously exposed to this level for a year, the total radiation level would be roughly equal to getting one CAT (CT) scan, according to the NISA. Additionally, this elevated level of radiation was never likely to continue.

2. Explosions have released radiation.

This one is true — but still not much of a concern. Imagine that the Fukushima reactor is a pot of Easy Mac on the stove, except the bits of noodle are radioactive fuel rods that must be kept cool. The easiest way to do that is to continuously pump several tons of water over the rods, which briefly heats up before it is flushed out and new water enters.

The 9.0 magnitude earthquake knocked out the water pumps, which meant the water already in the reactor was sitting still, and began heating up rapidly. Like Easy Mac, when water boils, steam is released. At Fukushima, some of this steam was composed of volatile hydrogen and a little iodine radiation. This hydrogen was vented out of the reactor, but built up in the building housing the reactor, which culminated in the reported explosions.

While these pictures looked frightening, they were of no major concern since the chamber containing the fuel rods had not been dangerously compromised. The amount of radiation was nothing compared to Chernobyl, which involved an explosion of the innermost containment unit. Many reports said that “explosions at nuclear reactors have taken place,” but hardly any said that “explosions have taken place but minimal radiation released.”

3. The Fukushima explosion is somehow worse than Three Mile Island.

This scary statement started when the International Atomic Energy Agency decided to bump up the rating of the Fukushima crisis from a 4 to a 5 on their International Nuclear Event Scale. This 7-step scale is supposed to provide a general idea of just how bad a nuclear crisis is.

First flaw: Fukushima is rated at the same level as Three Mile Island–not worse. Second flaw: Chernobyl is rated as a level 7, which doesn’t seem much worse, except for the fact the scale is logarithmic.

Translation: Chernobyl was 100 times more deadly than the Fukushima incident. Since nobody has died at either the Three Mile Island or Fukushima incidents, it’s hard for me to understand exactly why Fukushima is supposed to be the worst of the two. Is it in terms of property damage? Reported injuries? It seems this would be an important point the media should be specifying.

4. Workers have been exposed to radiation.

There’s a germ of truth here, but again, the media makes it sound much worse than it actually is. While people have been injured in the hydrogen explosions, none have come close to dying of radiation. According to an update from IAEA on March 18, 17 employees had received some dosage of radiation, but none had been hospitalized because the levels were so low.

5. People have been evacuated and given anti-radiation tablets.

True–but only as a precaution, not because they were in imminent danger of death. Plus, it makes sense to clear the area of potentially panicked pedestrians when emergency officials need to focus their attention on restoring lost electricity.

The “anti-radiation” tablets were actually iodine pills. The thyroid gland in humans absorbs iodine, so if the Fukushima reactor released radioactive iodine, the thyroid wouldn’t absorb any more. However, the amount of iodine released seems to be so small it won’t accumulate in dangerous levels.

The word ‘nuclear’ stirs up all kinds of emotions. Decades ago, it stopped the largest war the world had ever seen.

Future Drake journalists: Don’t forget that pot on the stove. Don’t let the ‘nuclear’ topic get too hot before you cool it with the correct information. It’s important to tell the story fast and tell it well, but don’t senselessly scare people who don’t know the full story the way so many news outlets did this past week. It is an unethical, irresponsible and cruel thing to do.

Tags: Current Events

MATT NELSON

Next Post

Muslim-American author to discuss her latest book, personal experience

Comments 1

  1. student says:
    10 years ago

    Thanks for stepping up and writing this article. I, too, am annoyed by the mainstream media and the uneducated people fussing about anything that uses the word “nuclear.”

Twitter Feeds

The Times-Delphic
The Times-Delphic @timesdelphic

hot cocoa in the superior cup tonight https://t.co/zxbBJvfh94
View on Twitter
timesdelphic photo
3
56
The Times-Delphic
The Times-Delphic @timesdelphic

Attached is The Times-Delphic statement on the recent BSC budget reduction proposal.
This statement was signed off by all other BSC organizations. https://t.co/2zQdLtphOI
View on Twitter
timesdelphic photo
28
91

Recommended

Attempt to conserve plastic unsuccessful

Attempt to conserve plastic unsuccessful

8 years ago
#NationalDogDay Everyday

#NationalDogDay Everyday

2 years ago

Popular News

  • Snapchat Streaks: fostering friendships or forcing communication?

    Snapchat Streaks: fostering friendships or forcing communication?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Gladwell’s “Outliers” reveals the many factors of success

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Several students test positive for COVID-19 in Goodwin-Kirk Residence Hall

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Drake ranks among Ivy Leagues on Economist list

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Drake Declines to Share Covid Data

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Student Perspectives on BLM Protests

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The rise and fall of Motown Records

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Don’t eat the rich: Argument against Occupy Wall Street ideas

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Student press is essential for letting students’ voices be heard

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Drake Greek Life Prepares for Recruitment During Covid

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Connect with us

  • About
  • Home
  • Podcasts
  • Privacy Policy
  • Virtual Edition
  • Advertising

Copyright 2015 Fuel Themes. All RIGHTS RESERVED.

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Administrative News
    • Campus Events
    • Campus Health
    • Caucus Roundup
    • In Des Moines
    • Politics
    • Student Politics
    • Student Senate
    • Senate Elections
  • Sports
    • Basketball
    • Column
    • Cross-Country
    • E-Sports
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Rowing
    • Soccer
    • Softball
  • Commentary
    • Horoscope
    • Letter from the Editor
  • Features
    • Greek Life
  • Podcasts
  • Relays Edition
    • Commentary
    • Coronavirus
    • Elections
    • Features
    • In Des Moines
    • News
    • This week in photos
    • Top News
    • Top Stories
    • Uncategorized
    • Video
    • Sports
    • Security Reports
    • Relays Edition
    • Poll
    • Podcasts
    • Online Exclusives
    • Opinion

Copyright 2015 Fuel Themes. All RIGHTS RESERVED.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist