• Home
  • Staff
  • Privacy Policy
  • News Tips/Press Releases
  • Advertising
Monday, May 23, 2022
No Result
View All Result
The Times-Delphic
  • News
    • All
    • Administrative News
    • Campus Events
    • Campus Health
    • Caucus Roundup
    • In Des Moines
    • Politics
    • Student Politics
    • Student Senate
    • The Ones

    Indira Sheumaker, city councilmembers find common ground among conflicts

    Drake urges community to remain cautious as reporting of new COVID-19 cases slows

    Drake urges community to remain cautious as reporting of new COVID-19 cases slows

    Drake to build University Center

    Student Senate passes resolution in support of the transgender community

    Drake welcomes first Black woman Student Body President

    Student Body President Morgan Coleman shares experiences as a leader

    • Administrative News
    • The Ones
    • Campus Events
    • Campus Health
    • Caucus Roundup
    • In Des Moines
    • Politics
    • Student Politics
    • Student Senate
    • Senate Elections
  • Sports
    • All
    • Baseball
    • Basketball
    • Column
    • Cross-Country
    • E-Sports
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Rowing
    • Soccer
    • Softball
    • Tennis
    • Track and Field
    • Volleyball

    Promising 2022 NFL Draft for Packers fans

    The two national parks you should visit this summer

    Des Moines lands news USL team and stadium district

    Former Drake Basketball Player Wins National Championship

    The Top Moves of NFL Free Agency

    • Basketball
    • Column
    • Cross-Country
    • E-Sports
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Rowing
    • Soccer
    • Softball
  • Commentary
    • All
    • Horoscope
    • Letter from the Editor
    • Letter to the Editor

    Hip astrology: Relays horoscope

    Painted Street ain’t so sweet when costs are heaped

    Commentary: Top 5 Self Care Tips

    Commentary: Top 5 Self Care Tips

    Commentary: How to meet your next partner in 2022

    Commentary: “Oh… We’re Not Dating…”

    • Horoscope
    • Letter from the Editor
  • Features
    • All
    • Greek Life
    Drake welcomes first Black woman Student Body President

    Student Body President Morgan Coleman shares experiences as a leader

    Painted Street recap

    Bam Bam wins Drake University’s 43rd annual Beautiful Bulldog Contest

    New Casey’s Location on Forest Avenue

    ADA student task force advocates for disability inclusion

    • Greek Life
  • Podcasts
    Drake Weekly Sports Podcast | December 3

    Drake Weekly Sports Podcast | December 3

    Drake Public Safety and the student body

    Drake Public Safety and the student body

    Humans of Drake Podcast

    Bulldog Blitz 1: December 7, 2010

    The Sports Report 2010 7: 11/09/2010

  • Relays Edition

    Bill that would make Iowa a hands-free driving state stalls in the legislature

    New Casey’s Location on Forest Avenue

    ADA student task force advocates for disability inclusion

    Des Moines lands news USL team and stadium district

    The Great Resignation: What Is It? And Why Is It Happening?

    The Great Resignation: What Is It? And Why Is It Happening?

    Hip astrology: Relays horoscope

    State of Sustainability at Drake

    Dean Kathleen Richardson: Leaving a Legacy for the Drake SJMC

    Painted Street ain’t so sweet when costs are heaped

    • Commentary
    • Coronavirus
    • Elections
    • Features
    • In Des Moines
    • News
    • This week in photos
    • Top News
    • Top Stories
    • Uncategorized
    • Video
    • Sports
    • Security Reports
    • Relays Edition
    • Poll
    • Podcasts
    • Online Exclusives
    • Opinion
  • News
    • All
    • Administrative News
    • Campus Events
    • Campus Health
    • Caucus Roundup
    • In Des Moines
    • Politics
    • Student Politics
    • Student Senate
    • The Ones

    Indira Sheumaker, city councilmembers find common ground among conflicts

    Drake urges community to remain cautious as reporting of new COVID-19 cases slows

    Drake urges community to remain cautious as reporting of new COVID-19 cases slows

    Drake to build University Center

    Student Senate passes resolution in support of the transgender community

    Drake welcomes first Black woman Student Body President

    Student Body President Morgan Coleman shares experiences as a leader

    • Administrative News
    • The Ones
    • Campus Events
    • Campus Health
    • Caucus Roundup
    • In Des Moines
    • Politics
    • Student Politics
    • Student Senate
    • Senate Elections
  • Sports
    • All
    • Baseball
    • Basketball
    • Column
    • Cross-Country
    • E-Sports
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Rowing
    • Soccer
    • Softball
    • Tennis
    • Track and Field
    • Volleyball

    Promising 2022 NFL Draft for Packers fans

    The two national parks you should visit this summer

    Des Moines lands news USL team and stadium district

    Former Drake Basketball Player Wins National Championship

    The Top Moves of NFL Free Agency

    • Basketball
    • Column
    • Cross-Country
    • E-Sports
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Rowing
    • Soccer
    • Softball
  • Commentary
    • All
    • Horoscope
    • Letter from the Editor
    • Letter to the Editor

    Hip astrology: Relays horoscope

    Painted Street ain’t so sweet when costs are heaped

    Commentary: Top 5 Self Care Tips

    Commentary: Top 5 Self Care Tips

    Commentary: How to meet your next partner in 2022

    Commentary: “Oh… We’re Not Dating…”

    • Horoscope
    • Letter from the Editor
  • Features
    • All
    • Greek Life
    Drake welcomes first Black woman Student Body President

    Student Body President Morgan Coleman shares experiences as a leader

    Painted Street recap

    Bam Bam wins Drake University’s 43rd annual Beautiful Bulldog Contest

    New Casey’s Location on Forest Avenue

    ADA student task force advocates for disability inclusion

    • Greek Life
  • Podcasts
    Drake Weekly Sports Podcast | December 3

    Drake Weekly Sports Podcast | December 3

    Drake Public Safety and the student body

    Drake Public Safety and the student body

    Humans of Drake Podcast

    Bulldog Blitz 1: December 7, 2010

    The Sports Report 2010 7: 11/09/2010

  • Relays Edition

    Bill that would make Iowa a hands-free driving state stalls in the legislature

    New Casey’s Location on Forest Avenue

    ADA student task force advocates for disability inclusion

    Des Moines lands news USL team and stadium district

    The Great Resignation: What Is It? And Why Is It Happening?

    The Great Resignation: What Is It? And Why Is It Happening?

    Hip astrology: Relays horoscope

    State of Sustainability at Drake

    Dean Kathleen Richardson: Leaving a Legacy for the Drake SJMC

    Painted Street ain’t so sweet when costs are heaped

    • Commentary
    • Coronavirus
    • Elections
    • Features
    • In Des Moines
    • News
    • This week in photos
    • Top News
    • Top Stories
    • Uncategorized
    • Video
    • Sports
    • Security Reports
    • Relays Edition
    • Poll
    • Podcasts
    • Online Exclusives
    • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
The Times-Delphic
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

Questions raised about one-for-one startup business

byMADELINE GOEBEL
February 19, 2015
in Opinion
0 0
1

STORY BY MADELINE GOEBEL AND MCKENZIE LEIER

On Jan. 19, four Drake students launched an ambitious startup business called Make Your Mark.
The company was featured in the Times-Delphic, and has gained substantial publicity within the Drake community.

The project surely has good intentions, but as many international development experts have noted, good intentions don’t always matter.
Make Your Mark is similar to the one-for-one model, in which purchasing a backpack will theoretically “guarantee the education of a child in a developing nation.”

A child gets an education, and you get to feel great about yourself and your new backpack.

Clearly it’s a win-win for everyone, right?

Not quite. The complications of traditional aid can be illustrated by numerous organizations, but TOMS shoes perhaps has the most parallels to Make Your Mark.

While TOMS was also started with very noble intentions, their business model does not address the disparate root causes of poverty in the various developing nations they operate in.

Rather, TOMS needs poor children without shoes in order to keep selling shoes.

TOMS has since adjusted their model. They sell eyewear, serve as a marketplace place for non-governmental organizations’s to sell local products and they recently built a manufacturing site in Haiti.

Regardless, TOMS’ initial ill-educated impact resulted from a lack of deep, local knowledge and a critical understanding of development.

When a child or person is simply handed a good or service, it takes away from the demand of that product or service.

Oftentimes, this takes a job away from a community member.

TOMS came to this realization, and has since started manufacturing shoes in countries where they distribute, starting with Haiti. This investment has boosted Haiti’s economy and empowered communities.

What’s the important lesson here? Outside intervention, especially from the Western world, can sometimes do more harm than good. Development projects cannot succeed without local understanding, partnerships and empowerment.

We fear this is exactly where Make Your Mark may be making a similar mistake.

The organization repeatedly reports on their media sites that it wishes to work in Africa, and has singled out Zimbabwe, Burkina Faso and Uganda simply for their low literacy rates.

Despite any solidified plans to operate on the continent, MYM contributes to the all-too-common white savior complex by stating its wishes to “save” Africa, thus perpetuating the stereotype that Africa needs to be saved.

While aspiring to improve our world and achieve educational equality is an admirable goal, it establishes a problematic power dynamic between those offering help and those receiving help.

It also fails to acknowledge global, political and economic systems that sustain inequality.

We do not intend to demean or discourage our fellow students from philanthropic or humanitarian efforts. Rather, we challenge you to seek understanding before you seek to help.

We challenge you to learn before making promises such as the eradication of poverty and the guarantee of an education.

We challenge you to think critically about the way you are representing Africa, Belize and the other communities you wish to work in.

We challenge you to approach global educational inequality from a position of solidarity and human dignity, not charity.

Some critics, such as Dambisa Moyo, author of “Dead Aid,” believe that traditional aid should be cut out entirely.

Moyo’s belief comes from the idea that governments should seek money from financial markets, and banks and companies should invest in these developing communities, not always simply give them handouts.

Organizations such as Kiva, Acumen and the Grameen Bank are pursuing poverty alleviation with similar ideologies and models.

While others believe in the educated dispersal of cold hard cash, the dispersal must be through the collaboration of local understanding.

The model set up by Drake’s very own Make Your Mark reflects a similar misunderstanding where so many have gone wrong.

MYM aims to allow for their partners to dictate where the money needs to be spent, rather than the imperialistic path that has been so popular in the past.

As Joy Sun spells out in her October 2014 TED talk, cash can often be the most effective form of aid.

Local people themselves know how best to use resources.

While the world of development is fraught with complications, one thing is for certain: Western solutions do not work for non-Western problems.

Next time you think of jumping on the charity bandwagon, we urge you to not just buy, but to understand.

We ask you to consider thinking about where your dollars and shoes are really going. Understand the implications of your actions.

Realize that you are a contributor to the world, big or small.

As college students and global citizens, we have a responsibility to the world.

We are the next generation. Allow yourselves to use your education for good.

Take the beautiful opportunity you were given in the form of a higher education and make a positive mark on the world.

Tags: Charityopinionstudent businessStudent Organizations

MADELINE GOEBEL

Next Post

Beware of too much ‘stranger danger’

Comments 1

  1. Justin says:
    7 years ago

    Great article, ladies. Fantastic point that needed to be heard.

    It reminded me of Drake Football’s trip to Egypt in 2011 (?)… they built houses in a country with an overwhelmingly high rate of unemployment. Great surface value charity, plus the whole feel good thing / publicity, but every swing of the hammer is someone’s job. Not to say that there aren’t individuals in the area living without shelter, but this offers relatively no sustainability or bettering of the community once they pack up and fly home. Surely there must have been a better way to allocate those resources than 100+ plane tickets for a week of unskilled manual labor.

    There is a great Latin saying that is used in emergency medicine, and it translates beautifully to aide / development- “nil nocere”, meaning, “first, do no harm”.

Twitter Feeds

The Times-Delphic
The Times-Delphic @timesdelphic

BREAKING: Drake President Marty Martin announced in a campuswide email that Drake's number of active cases is projected to decline to 80 by the end of the day, down 241 since early Friday afternoon.
View on Twitter
2
10
The Times-Delphic
The Times-Delphic @timesdelphic

We've added an update to this article about the COVID-19 surge on campus. https://t.co/MaXtlQ4w2j
View on Twitter
0
4

Recommended

Upcoming Games & Events (August 22-28)

11 years ago
Drake Theatre announces production of Medea

Reviewing “Medea” by Drake Theatre

7 months ago

Popular News

  • Twitch Streamer Raises Money for LGBT Community

    Twitch Streamer Raises Money for LGBT Community

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Gladwell’s “Outliers” reveals the many factors of success

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Drake ranks among Ivy Leagues on Economist list

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The history of Indian boarding schools in Iowa

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Music as a political platform

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Drake Weekly Sports Podcast | December 3

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Humans of Drake Podcast

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The Sports Report 2010 7: 11/09/2010

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Familiar face helps bring massive skatepark to Des Moines

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The rise and fall of Motown Records

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Connect with us

  • About
  • Home
  • Podcasts
  • Privacy Policy
  • Virtual Edition
  • Advertising

Copyright 2015 Fuel Themes. All RIGHTS RESERVED.

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Administrative News
    • The Ones
    • Campus Events
    • Campus Health
    • Caucus Roundup
    • In Des Moines
    • Politics
    • Student Politics
    • Student Senate
    • Senate Elections
  • Sports
    • Basketball
    • Column
    • Cross-Country
    • E-Sports
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Rowing
    • Soccer
    • Softball
  • Commentary
    • Horoscope
    • Letter from the Editor
  • Features
    • Greek Life
  • Podcasts
  • Relays Edition
    • Commentary
    • Coronavirus
    • Elections
    • Features
    • In Des Moines
    • News
    • This week in photos
    • Top News
    • Top Stories
    • Uncategorized
    • Video
    • Sports
    • Security Reports
    • Relays Edition
    • Poll
    • Podcasts
    • Online Exclusives
    • Opinion

Copyright 2015 Fuel Themes. All RIGHTS RESERVED.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Bodybuilder is fighting for his life after taking dirty steroids femara uk trump's "operation warp speed" for mass vaxxing. "big bucks for big pharma" - global research